Optics and Perception

“Optics” used to mean, “the science of light.”

Until recently, the only definition of the English word optics I was familiar with is this one:

optics noun: (plural usually treated as singular) a science that deals with light, its genesis and propagation, the effects that it undergoes and produces, and other phenomena closely associated with it —Merriam-Webster Unabridged Dictionary.

Then I noticed it being used in a very different sense:

To put it mildly, the optics of firing Comey are terrible.

Once I noticed that example, many more jumped out at me. Here are a few:

[Because the Republican committee on health care is made up of 13 senators, none of them women], CNN’s Inside Politics host John King speculated about whether Republican leadership should, “for optics purposes, have tinkered with the working group.” Appearing as a guest on the same show, CNN’s Jeff Zeleny agreed with King that excluding women was “optically terrible.”

The issue itself is secondary to the optics of the Democrats opposing this administration in a high-profile way.

The optics are terrible, but it’s also a terrible waste of government money.

In each of these examples, the word optics is being used as I would use the word perception, to mean, “the way in which something is regarded, understood, or interpreted,” or appearance, “the way things look.”

The noun perception and its verb perceive are often used in contrast to the word reality:

Sometimes, Perception is Just as Important as Reality

In the world of security, there is often a significant difference between perceived reality and what is actually happening.

Facts matter not at all. Perception is everything.

We need to challenge many popular perceptions of old age.

Why take a scientific term like optics and start using it to replace ordinary words like perception and appearances? Possibly to obscure meaning.

It’s not clear who was first to use optics in the sense of perception. According to a 2010 article in the New York Times, it may have begun with bilingual Canadian political writers. In French, the word optique means both “the science of optics” and “perspective or point of view.”

In a 2009 On Language column, William Safire referred to this use of optics as a new buzzword in American usage, but about thirty years earlier, in 1978, Jimmy Carter’s special counselor on inflation, Robert Strauss, said that inviting certain business leaders to the White House “would be a nice optical step.”

In my view, optics in the sense of perception or appearances is pompous jargon suited to politicians and other speakers whose purpose is to muddy communication. Writers and speakers who are committed to plain speaking and truth telling should probably leave it alone.

 

Stint and Stent

It’s not uncommon to see comments like these in web postings:
The artery was far too small to fit a stint.
Initially, they put in a stint and ordered an ERCP to determine the nature of the mass causing the blockage. 
They went in, got the stone, and put in a stint so any future stones would just

Continue reading Stint and Stent

Word Rage: Anger Management for US English Speakers

Maeve’s new collection of essays, WORD RAGE, covers most of the topics that spark heated online “grammar” debates and interfere with true communication.

Continue reading Word Rage: Anger Management for US English Speakers

Maeve's Writing Guide Reformatted

Buyer Beware: The old version of Maeve’s writing guide is still available on Amazon in a white cover with a yellow edge. Don’t buy that one. Buy the new one with the computer on the

Continue reading Maeve’s Writing Guide Reformatted

Jeopardy: Stanch and Staunch

Jeopardy clues are written by a team of nine writers. One of their goals is to ensure there’s only one possible response, but they don’t always

Continue reading Note to Jeopardy: stanch and staunch are different words

The Difference Between "Advise" and "Advice"

If you’re selling, spelling counts. People who write for a living have no excuse to misuse ordinary English

Continue reading The Difference Between “Advise” and “Advice”

February

The disconnect between the spelling and pronunciation of some English words is not a sinister plot to annoy English

Continue reading February

Beware of Whom with Parenthetical Expressions

This morning the following caption appeared in a Democrat-Gazette article about a bank robbery:
Springdale police are searching for this man whom they say robbed an Arvest Bank branch Thursday.
The error with whom in this caption is common in sentences that contain a parenthetical phrase or clause: a group of words thrown into another clause, separating

Continue reading Beware of “Whom” with Parenthetical Expressions

New Word: DeVossed

A Google search for “devossed” in quotation marks brings up only 521 hits on February 9, 2017, but my spidey sense tells me this word is destined to achieve greater numbers in the following weeks and months.
The Urban Dictionary has already posted an entry:
DEVOSSED: When the last tiny shred of hope is shattered. Origin: Betsy

Continue reading New Word: DeVossed

10 Requests to the Press

Please stop reaching for false equivalencies in an effort to appear unbiased. You’re not being biased when you acknowledge that something bad is

Continue reading 10 Requests to the Press